The Darkness of Golgotha

Matthew 27:46 G. Campbell Morgan
Thesis The three hours of darkness at Golgotha represent the central mystery of the atonement—a period when Christ experienced complete forsakenness under the assault of evil powers, choosing not to save Himself in order to accomplish the salvation of humanity.
Series
—
Type
Expository
Tone
didacticpastoralcelebratory
Method
grammatical-historicalredemptive-historicalcanonical
What's in this sermon

The shape of the argument

28 units across exposition, application, illustration, theological claim, and conclusion. The pastor's argument is built from these moving parts.

Pastoral correction · unit #25
"Morgan moves from theological exposition to personal testimony and universal application. Though the precise transaction remains mysterious, its effect is certain—those who come to the cross find actual forgiveness, healing, and cleansing. He declares the exclusivity of the cross as the only path to genuine forgiveness."
Doctrinal loci· 9 surfaced
Christology · 22 Soteriology · 15 Spiritual Warfare · 6 Anthropology · 4 Hamartiology · 4 Bibliology · 2 Theology Proper · 2 Eschatology · 1 Providence / Sovereignty · 1
Bible citations· 20
Matthew 27:46 | John 19:28 | John 19:30 | Luke 23:46 | Luke 22:53 | John 9:4 | Ephesians 2:2 | John 1:9 | Matthew 4:16 | Matthew 6:23 | Matthew 8:12 | Matthew 25:30 | Colossians 2:15 | Matthew 21:42 | Matthew 27:42 | Isaiah 45:3
Theological claims· 8
  1. The three hours of darkness represent the time when all the concentrated force of evil was brought to bear on the soul of the Son of God in an attempt to extinguish the Light. unit #8
  2. The physical darkness at Golgotha was likely produced by Satan and the powers of darkness as the material manifestation of the spiritual assault on Christ. unit #9
  3. Just as the Incarnation manifested God materially, the darkness at Golgotha manifested spiritual evil materially, coinciding with Christ's ultimate suffering. unit #11
  4. In the darkness, Christ triumphed over Satan and the principalities and powers, stripping them of their authority and displaying their defeat through the cross. unit #16
  5. Christ's final words 'Father, into Thy hands I commend My spirit' declare that the transaction within the darkness was fully accomplished. unit #20
  6. Christ could not save Himself because God is love, and love is never satisfied with the destruction of sinners but only with their salvation and restoration to the image of God. unit #23
  7. Love could find no other way to forgive sin because human conscience demands not mere overlooking of sin but actual cleansing through a transaction mightier than sin itself. unit #24
  8. In the darkness Christ deliberately chose not to save Himself in order to accomplish my salvation from sin. unit #26
Quotations· 1
"Love so amazing, so divine" — Unknown hymn writer (unit #18)
Read it

Full transcript

23,265 characters 28 units ~26 min reading time

0 · Morgan establishes the gravity of the passage by warning against superficial reading

THERE'S ALWAYS THE danger that we might read this verse too quickly. We treat it too often as though it were merely the record of something incidental. As a matter of fact, it is the central verse in the story of the cross. Indeed, the cross itself is not mentioned in the verse-no word is spoken of it or of the Christ. They are alike hidden, and yet the period was one of three hours' duration, the very central hours of the experience of the Savior of men. Christ and the cross are alike hidden within that verse, and that fact is most suggestive because in those hours transactions were accomplished that through all eternity defy the apprehension and explanation of finite minds.

1 · Morgan notes the synoptic consensus on recording the darkness, establishing its significance

It is not to be passed over lightly that all the Synoptists record the fact of that darkness. Three hours of darkness and of silence! All the ribald clamor was over, the material opposition utterly exhausted, the turmoil ended. Man had done his last and his worst. Beyond that period of the three hours' silence, even human actions were expressive of pity.

2 · Morgan traces a dramatic psychological shift in the witnesses after the darkness—from mockery and hostility to pity, awe, and reverence

Nothing has impressed my own heart, or amazed me more in reading this story anew, and attempting to meditate upon it in view of this service, than what I shall venture to describe as the wonderful psychological conditions of those hours beyond the hours of silence. It is as though that appalling silence and that overwhelming darkness had changed the entire attitude of man to the Savior. The very vinegar they offered Him to drink was offered Him in pity. What they said about Elijah was expressive of their desire to sympathize. The centurion's testimony was that of a man whose heart was strangely moved toward the August and dignified Savior. When presently they found Him dead, and therefore did not break His bones, the spear thrust was one of kindness, lest perchance He might still suffer, in spite of the fact that He appeared to be dead. Multitudes dispersed from the scene at Golgotha smiting their breasts, overwhelmed with a sense of awe, and strangely moved by some new pity. And there is no picture in all the New Testament more full of pathos and of power than that of the women standing silent and amazed through all those hours of His suffering, and still standing there beyond them.

3 · Morgan examines the four post-darkness utterances of Christ, noting their sequential significance: the cry of forsakenness (past tense, emerging from experience), the physical need ('I thirst'), the proclamation of completion, and the final committal to the Father

Then also all of the cries that passed the lips of Jesus beyond the darkness were significant. "My God! My God, why didst Thou forsake Me!"— Matthew 27:46 —for that was the tense; a slight change from the tense of the actual Psalm, a question asked by One who was emerging from the experience to which He referred. And then as John is most careful to record for us , "Knowing that all things were now finished, He said, I thirst"— John 19:28 . Beyond that came the words of the great proclamation, "It is finished"— John 19:30 . And as last the words of the final committal, full of dignity, were spoken: "Father, into Thy hands I commend My spirit"— Luke 23:46 . Everything was changed beyond the hours of silence and of darkness.

4 · Morgan systematically refutes three inadequate explanations of the darkness: solar eclipse (astronomically impossible at Passover), nature's sympathy (pagan anthropomorphism), and divine sympathy (contradicted by Christ's own testimony of forsakenness)

Much has been written about these hours of darkness, much which is not warranted by any careful spiritual attention to the story itself. You will call to mind how, at great length many years ago, it was argued that the darkness was that of the sun's eclipse. But that is entirely impossible, for Passover was always held at full moon, when there could be no eclipse of the sun. The darkness has been described as nature's sympathy with the suffering of the Lord, but that is a pagan conception of nature, a conception of nature as having some consciousness apart from God and out of harmony with His work. It has been said that the darkness was brought about by an act of God, and was expressive of His sympathy with His Son. I admit that that is an appealing idea, and has some element of truth in it, in that we may discover the overruling of His government; but to declare that that darkness was caused by God because of His sympathy with His Son is to deny the cry of Jesus which immediately followed the darkness and referred to it. The darkness was to Him a period when He experienced whatever He may have meant by the words, "Thou didst forsake Me"— Matthew 27:46 .

5 · Morgan establishes his hermeneutical principle—only Christ's own testimony can interpret the darkness—and outlines the sermon's three-part structure: the meaning of the darkness, the passing of the darkness, and the transaction within the darkness

If I have succeeded in these words spoken in reverent spirit, in suggesting to you the difficulty of those central three hours, then our hearts are prepared for going forward. I submit thoughtfully that no interpretation of that darkness is to be trusted save that of the Lord who experienced it. Has He flung any light on the darkness which will enable us to apprehend the meaning of the darkness? Did any word escape His lips that will help us to explain those silent hours? I think the answer is to be found in these narratives, and to that teaching of the Lord we appeal in order that we may consider the meaning of the darkness, and the passing of the darkness, and thereafter attempt reverently to look back at the transaction in the darkness.

Where this fits

More from G. Campbell Morgan

The other sermons stewarded in this G. Campbell Morgan set.

Personal appropriation of Christ's cleansing through obedient surrender is the only path from the tragedy of privileged unbelief to the blessing of transformation, and the sole obstacles to this cleansing are preconceived notions about God's methods and the prideful attempt to dictate terms to Him.
2 Kings 5
Being filled with the Spirit is not a privilege for the spiritually elite but a divine command for all believers, achievable through total abandonment to God and maintained through obedient abiding in Christ, manifesting not in predictable sensations but in the lived reality of Christ's Lordship.
Ephesians 5:18
This sermon
The Darkness of Golgotha
The three hours of darkness at Golgotha represent the central mystery of the atonement—a period when Christ experienced complete forsakenness under the assault of evil powers, choosing not to save Himself in order to accomplish the salvation of humanity.
Matthew 27:46
Take it further

Discuss · apply

Small-group discussion

6 questions for your group this week

  1. In Matthew 27:46, Jesus cries out 'My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?' What does the sermon suggest was actually happening during those three hours of darkness that prompted this cry—and how is it different from what the disciples or onlookers might have assumed was occurring?
    Matthew 27:46
    → What makes this moment distinct from other times in Scripture when God's people have felt abandoned or distant from Him?
  2. Morgan traces Jesus's references throughout His ministry to 'an hour' that was coming—culminating in Gethsemane when He says 'This is your hour, and the power of darkness' (Luke 22:53). What does this pattern suggest about how Jesus understood the cross not as an accident or tragedy, but as something He was deliberately moving toward?
    Luke 22:53
  3. The sermon argues that the physical darkness at Golgotha was not a natural phenomenon or God's distant sympathy, but rather the material manifestation of spiritual evil assaulting the soul of Christ. How does this understanding reshape what we see happening on the cross—and what does it tell us about the nature and reality of the spiritual conflict that culminated there?
    Colossians 2:15
    → In what ways does recognizing the cross as a genuine battle against evil powers change how we understand Christ's victory?
  4. Morgan emphasizes that Christ 'could not save Himself' not because He lacked power, but because 'God is love'—and love cannot be satisfied with merely overlooking sin but demands actual cleansing and restoration. What does this reveal about why the cross was necessary rather than optional? Could God have simply forgiven sin without it?
  5. The sermon concludes that from the darkness of Golgotha have come 'the treasures of darkness'—pardon, peace, power, and purity for all who come to the cross. When you consider Christ's deliberate choice not to save Himself in order to accomplish your salvation, how does that reshape the way you receive and respond to His forgiveness?
    Isaiah 45:3
    → What is the difference between theoretically knowing you are pardoned and experiencing the healing of your conscience that comes from actually coming to the cross?
  6. As we move into this week, what does it mean practically to 'come to the cross' in the way the sermon describes—to receive not just theoretical pardon but actual cleansing? What would that look like for you in your struggle with a specific sin or shame you carry?
Couples · three questions over coffee

The Darkness and Our Salvation

  1. What stirred in your heart as you heard about Christ's forsakenness in the darkness—and what does it mean to you that He chose not to save Himself so that you could be saved?
  2. How does understanding the costliness of our forgiveness—that Christ endured the concentrated assault of evil to cleanse our conscience—change the way we relate to each other's sin and failure in our marriage?
  3. What specific area of your life or heart needs the healing that flows from the cross, and how can we pray for one another as we bring that need before the Father together?
Daily readings · Monday–Friday

5-day reading plan

This week we meditate on the mystery of Golgotha's darkness—tracing how Christ's forsakenness became the power of our redemption, from the assault of evil to the triumph of love.

Monday Luke 22:53

Jesus tells His arresters, 'This is your hour, and the power of darkness.' Morgan shows us that Golgotha's darkness was not accident or symbol but the deliberate, concentrated hour when Satan and the principalities brought their full force against the Light of the world. In this passage, Christ acknowledges the hour as theirs—yet even in that acknowledgment, He moves toward the cross with sovereign intention, demonstrating that the darkness could never overcome His purpose.

Tuesday John 1:9

Scripture declares Christ as 'the true light that enlightens everyone.' The three hours of darkness at Golgotha represent evil's attempt to eclipse this eternal Light through material, palpable means—a darkness we could see because it was darkness aimed at Him whom no darkness can contain. Just as the Incarnation made God's glory visible in flesh, so the darkness made the assault of evil visible in the material world, allowing us to grasp something of the spiritual transaction occurring in that silence.

Wednesday Colossians 2:15

Paul declares that Christ 'disarmed the rulers and authorities and put them to open shame, by triumphing over them in him.' The darkness of Golgotha was not Satan's victory but the stage of his defeat—the very hour when evil's concentrated assault met the immeasurable grace of the Son of God choosing not to save Himself. From that apparent triumph of darkness came the stripping bare of all demonic authority and the public declaration of Christ's supremacy over every power.

Thursday Isaiah 45:3

God speaks of giving 'treasures of darkness' to those who walk in the darkness, knowing that He is with them. Morgan shows us that from Christ's unfathomable darkness in our place have come treasures immeasurable for all who approach the cross: the actual cleansing of conscience, the restoration of the image of God, and the peace that only a transaction mightier than sin itself can produce. We do not romanticize the darkness, but we recognize it as the sole source of our redemption.

Friday Luke 23:46

After the silence and the cry, Christ speaks this word of surrender and consummation—not as defeat but as completion. His commending of His spirit to the Father declares that the mystery of the darkness is finished, the ransom is paid, and the love of God that could find no other way to save us has accomplished what only such a transaction could accomplish. We come to the cross because Christ finished there what we could never finish ourselves: the work of our salvation and restoration in the image of God.

Memory verse this week

Matthew 27:46

And about the ninth hour Jesus cried out with a loud voice, saying, 'Eli, Eli, lema sabachthani?' that is, 'My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?'

Why this verse: This is the cry that emerges from the darkness—the central mystery of the atonement that Morgan unpacks throughout the sermon. It testifies to Christ's experience of complete forsakenness under the assault of evil powers, and from that unfathomable darkness comes the transaction by which He chose not to save Himself in order to save us.

Sunday-evening family table

Why Jesus Didn't Save Himself

For the parent

This prompt invites children to grapple with the paradox at the heart of the cross—that Jesus's refusal to use His power to escape suffering was actually the way He saved us. Listen for their instinct to 'fix' the problem, then gently help them see that real love sometimes means staying in the hard place for someone else's sake.

The preacher said that when Jesus was on the cross in that darkness, He could have saved Himself—He had the power to do it. But He chose not to. Why do you think Jesus would choose to stay there and suffer instead of using His power to get away? What does that tell us about what He was doing for us?
works for ages 8+ — younger children can listen and offer simple answers; older kids and teens can wrestle with the paradox of power, love, and sacrifice
Where this was preached

About the preacher

G. Campbell Morgan
More samples →
Crawler & AI-search policy · view robots.txt and llms.txt

This sermon page is intentionally optimized for search engines and AI assistants. We've opted into being crawled by both. The crawler-config files at the domain root:

/robots.txt
User-agent: *
Allow: /

User-agent: GPTBot
Allow: /

User-agent: ClaudeBot
Allow: /

User-agent: Google-Extended
Allow: /

User-agent: PerplexityBot
Allow: /

Sitemap: https://sermonsteward.com/sitemap.xml
/llms.txt
# Westminster Chapel · London

Significant sermons by G. Campbell Morgan, stewarded by Sermon Steward as a sample.

## Sermons
- [Naaman - or the Second But (2 Kings 5)](/SignificantSermons/morgan/sermons/naaman-or-the-second-but)
- [Be Filled With the Spirit (Ephesians 5:18)](/SignificantSermons/morgan/sermons/be-filled-with-the-spirit)
- [The Darkness of Golgotha (Matthew 27:46)](/SignificantSermons/morgan/sermons/the-darkness-of-golgotha)

## About
- About the church
- Plan a visit

The page itself ships with Schema.org Article + Church markup, Open Graph + Twitter cards for share previews, and a canonical URL. Transcripts are server-rendered HTML — no JS dependency for the readable body.