When a Snake Takes the Stand
Thesis Christians must become discerning judges of slander, treating false witness with the biblical severity it deserves while clinging to the hope that Christ's death secures citizenship in a place where lies are no more.
The shape of the argument
34 units across exposition, application, illustration, theological claim, and conclusion. The pastor's argument is built from these moving parts.
- cultural reference · unit #7 — Illustrates the retributive justice principle of Deuteronomy 19 through the narrative of To Kill a Mockingbird. Mayella Ewell's false accusation of sexual assault would, under biblical law, carry the same penalty as the crime alleged. The illustration makes vivid the severity of the biblical standard.
- analogy · unit #12 — Explains confabulation as a medical condition resulting from alcohol abuse — the brain invents false memories to fill gaps. Connects this to the biblical concept of sober-mindedness as a diagnostic category for clear thinking versus self-deception.
- cultural reference · unit #26 — Cites psychological research on verbal abuse to illustrate the danger of internalizing slander — depression, anxiety, self-destruction, and 'broken mirror syndrome.' Reinforces the application: once someone is identified as a slanderer, the proper response is to move on and cling to God's truth.
- historical example · unit #27 — Introduces John Calvin as a historical example of a godly man frequently slandered. Theodore Beza's testimony at Calvin's death establishes both Calvin's character and the inevitability that excellence invites slander.
- historical example · unit #28 — Calvin's own reflection on slander, describing Satan's strategy of using false reports to terrify and overturn good conscience. Calvin identifies the natural desire for vindication and warns of the danger of being overwhelmed by false accusations.
- personal story · unit #31 — Personal travel anecdote illustrating the difference between littered and clean environments. The pervasive visual noise of trash creates mental strain; the absence of litter creates peace and clarity. Sets up the analogy to a world without lies.
- The very first sin ever committed was Satan's false witness against God, and the second sin was believing that false witness — establishing slander as the foundational spiritual problem. unit #2
- The biblical standard for handling slander applies equally to the informal court of public opinion as it does to formal judicial proceedings. unit #10
- Slander is the intentional or unintentional spreading of falsehoods that threaten damage to another person's reputation, and it manifests through various rhetorical errors including embellishment, confabulation, and assigning motives. unit #11
- Slander is evil whether in a courtroom or a chat room, and it deserves not only to be identified but penalized. unit #14
- Slanderers are not victims but villains against the foundation of society; by eroding trust, they replace progress with paranoia and threaten human flourishing. unit #16
- God Himself will destroy the slanderer; the law keeper never misses his man, and unrepentant slanderers will eternally confess their defeat. unit #22
"In short, we talk about the cross affecting three things, the root, the fruit, and the brute." — Sinclair Ferguson (unit #0)
"it is forbidden of God among the heinous, damning sins of slander. It is forbidden of God among the heinous, damning sins and made the character of a notorious person." — Richard Baxter (unit #8)
"take my riches and at the very least you'll be richer... take my reputation? I'm bankrupt and you have nothing." — William Shakespeare (unit #11)
"the whole world runs on faith and trust and pixie dust" — J.M. Barrie (writer of Peter Pan) (unit #16)
"wherever the apostle Paul went there were either revivals or riots and everywhere I go they serve tea" — unnamed Anglican bishop (unit #24)
"having been a spectator of his conduct for 16 years, I can now declare that in him all men may see a most beautiful example of the Christian character, an example which is easy to slander as it is difficult to imitate." — Theodore Beza (unit #27)
"Godly men, even when they do well, must be exposed to evil reports. By these strategies, Satan attacks our faith and unjustly slanders us among men. The temptation to be terrified by such reports is highly dangerous. For we want our integrity to be well known. When we are well disposed, we take it ill if other men put a different interpretation on our conduct. Satan tries by slander to overturn all that we have done out of a good conscience. For he accuses us of something that we are not at all guilty of. or he loads us with unfounded slanders or contrives what never came into our minds." — John Calvin (unit #28)
Full transcript
0 · Introduces the sermon's focus on the ninth commandment through a theological essay by Sinclair Ferguson identifying Satan as the deceiver
This week I was browsing through a collection of essays written by the great Sinclair Ferguson and landed on an essay entitled, Naming the Enemy. At the beginning of the essay, he talks about the three-dimensional work of the cross, namely that the cross deals with our sinfulness, which is the power that sin has over us. It also deals with our various specific sins, the various sins we commit that bring guilt upon us. And the cross also deals with Satan. And it was easy as I read that to think of Sinclair Ferguson's deep Scottish brogue as he said the following, In short, we talk about the cross affecting three things, the root, the fruit, and the brute. The root, the fruit, and the brute. No, that doesn't practice. That's just natural right there. The root, the fruit, and the brute. And his essay, of course, was dealing with this third thing, the brute, Satan himself. He went on to describe that almost every name that is connected to Satan is in some way connected to his role as a deceiver. One of his titles in Scripture is the deceiver, and another title in Scripture is the accuser. And then, of course, even the name devil, I remember finding this out in the Greek when I was learning Greek a long time ago, thinking, oh my goodness. Even the name devil has this idea of throwing something, as if throwing out an accusation, throwing out a falsehood to someone. Mudslinging is maybe how we would think about it. And then, of course, the word Satan. Most commentators suggest that the root of the name Satan is actually the idea of someone ambushing, sneaking out from a bush and ambushing someone. So all of these names for Satan manifest in the original story of the first sin that ever took place in the world.
1 · Reads Genesis 3:1-5 in full, the biblical account of Satan's temptation of Eve
And I want to read that to you from Genesis 3. Genesis 3.1, Now the serpent was more crafty than any other beast of the field that the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, Did God actually say, You shall not eat of any tree in the garden? And the woman said to the serpent, We may eat of the fruit of the trees in the garden. But God said, You shall not eat of the fruit of the tree that is in the midst of the garden, neither shall you touch it, lest you die. But the serpent said to the woman, You will surely not die. For God knows that when you eat of it, your eyes will be open, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.
2 · Interprets the Genesis passage to establish a doctrinal claim: the first sin was Satan's slander of God, and the second was Eve's belief of the lie
There we see Satan bearing false witness about God. You will surely not die, Satan says. For God knows, assigning motive, that when you eat of it, your eyes will be open, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil. I suppose you could say that the very first sin to ever have been committed on the face of the earth was committed by the devil, and it pertains to the ninth commandment, which we're looking at today, the idea of bearing false witness. The very first sin that ever happened in the world was committed by the devil, and it was the sin of false witness, slandering God. And what's the second sin to have ever been committed in the world? Well, I suppose you might say that the second sin was the sin committed by Eve, and that was to believe the lies.
3 · Announces the sermon's dual texts and pivots from exposition to the sermon's primary aim: equipping the congregation to discern slander rather than merely condemning it
Well, that's where I want to spend the majority of our time this morning. Our text is both Exodus 20.16, which says, You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor, and Deuteronomy 19.15-21, which gets into the details of how to handle slander. And of course, I could preach a message about how slander is wrong, and I suppose I will do that. But really, what I wanted to do today is to equip you to be a discerning hearer. I want to equip you knowing that the world is full of slander, and that potentially every day of your life, lies will land on your little cute ears. And you need to learn how to discern. I think that's the gift that we would ask the Lord for this morning, Lord, please help us to be more discerning with all that we hear, with all that is being said in the world.
4 · Introduces Deuteronomy 19 as case law explicating the ninth commandment
And for that, let's turn to this text in Deuteronomy. Deuteronomy 19 is sort of a commentary on the command, the ninth commandment, not to slander. Deuteronomy 19 is sort of how to handle this when it arises in a public, formal court setting. So let me read verse 15 to you just to give you an idea of what's going on here. A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or three witnesses shall a charge be established.
5 · Expounds the social context and protective logic of the two-or-three-witness rule
So once again, this is dealing with a formal court setting, with formal charges and formal penalties. And the idea here is is that there would be a great temptation to sabotage someone you didn't like by bringing a false accusation against that person into a court, right? You get with a friend because the rule is two or three. You get with a friend, you find another co-conspirator and you make an accusation against so-and-so so to take them down. Maybe you want their property, maybe you want their wife, whatever. The point is is that there's a pretty easy means within this court system to take someone down. All you have to do is bring a false allegation. So what we see in verse 16 is how to process that possibility. God is quite careful. Let me pause for a moment and say, it is better in biblical justice for a guilty man to go free than for an innocent man to be punished. Everything wired in the biblical justice system is wired in that direction. So there may be people who have committed terrible crimes for which there were not two or three witnesses and the Bible would rather let those people go knowing that God is the great avenger than to falsely penalize someone who was not indeed guilty. This is a passage kind of about all of that.
Recent preaching context
The three sermons immediately preceding this one in the preaching schedule.
Discuss · apply · pray
What the Snake Said About God
This prompt invites kids to notice Satan's first lie — his false witness against God's character in Eden — and connects it to how lies damage trust today. Listen for whether your kids can name what Satan claimed versus what was actually true, and help them see that slander has always been the enemy's weapon.
In the sermon, Chris talked about Satan's first lie in the garden: he told Eve that God was holding out on her, that God didn't want her to be like Him. But what was actually true about God? What was God actually doing? And then — if Satan's first move was to lie about God, why do you think lies and false stories are still such a big deal today?
6 questions for your group this week
-
Chris traced slander back to Satan's lie in Genesis 3, where he told Eve that God was holding out on her. What made that first false witness so destructive, and how do you see that same pattern of 'God is not trustworthy' showing up in lies we encounter today?Genesis 3:1-5→ Can you think of a specific lie circulating in your own circle right now that, at its root, suggests God cannot be trusted?
-
The sermon defined slander as the intentional or unintentional spreading of falsehoods that threaten damage to reputation. Why does the text hold someone accountable for unintentional false witness the same way it does intentional lying, and what does that say about our responsibility when we pass on information we're not certain about?Deuteronomy 19:16-19
-
Chris mentioned that sincerity does not equal truth—that we can sincerely believe something false about another person through assigning motives, universalizing, or treating feelings as facts. When have you caught yourself doing one of these three things, and what would it have taken to stop before you spread it?→ What difference does it make to know that the other person might sincerely believe their accusation about you is true?
-
The sermon argued that we all have a bias—either toward the powerful or toward the powerless—and that unexamined bias causes lies to gain traction. Which direction do you naturally lean, and how might that bias make you more susceptible to believing slander?Leviticus 19:15
-
Chris said that when slander targets you, the proper response is not introspection seeking truth in the accusation, but recognition that God does not use the accuser as an instrument of your sanctification. How does that reframe the way you should respond the next time someone spreads a falsehood about you?Deuteronomy 19:20-21→ What would it look like to grieve the lie without taking ownership of it, and to pursue vindication without bitterness?
-
The sermon closed by pointing us to communion—a foretaste of a world where lies are no more and only truth, beauty, and goodness remain. How does that future hope change the way you should handle slander now, in a world still full of lies?Matthew 5:11
Prayer for Discernment Against Slander
Father, we come before you as a people who have been shaped by lies from the beginning. Satan's first and foundational sin was bearing false witness against you in Eden — slandering your character, your motives, your goodness — and we, your image-bearers, have inherited his pattern. We confess that we have spread falsehoods about one another, sometimes with malice and sometimes in self-deception, not realizing that sincerity does not equal truth. We have assigned motives we could not possibly know. We have universalized from single incidents. We have treated our feelings as facts and called it testimony. We have robbed our brothers and sisters of their most precious commodity — their reputation — and we have done damage we cannot fully repair.
Yet we praise you that you are a God of truth, and that in Christ you have borne the full weight of slander. He was accused falsely. He was slandered before Pilate and before the crowds. He carried our lies to the cross and paid the penalty we deserve. Through his blood, we are cleansed not only of our own slanders but of every false accusation ever leveled against us. You do not use the accuser of the brethren as an instrument of our sanctification (Revelation 12:10). You use your Word, your Spirit, and your people speaking the truth in love.
Give us the grace this week to become discerning judges of slander. Guard us from the bias that makes us credulous toward accusations against those we distrust and defensive toward accusations against those we love. Help us to check our personal leanings, to demand evidence, to expect biblical procedure, and to recognize the rhetorical patterns of deception when we encounter them. When we are slandered, grant us the courage to stand firm in the truth of who we are in Christ, and the wisdom to know when silence is strength and when speaking is necessary. Most of all, remind us that you do not miss your man — every unrepentant slanderer will one day confess their defeat, and you are establishing a kingdom where lies have no home, where only truth, beauty, and goodness remain forever.
We commit ourselves to be speakers of truth, defenders of the innocent, and witnesses to the world that Christ has won the victory over the father of lies. To your glory and the healing of your people, we pray. Amen.
Guarding Each Other's Name
- Where did you feel the weight of the sermon's claim that slander — whether we're speaking it or believing it — is a foundational spiritual problem? What stirred in you?
- How have false narratives or unexamined assumptions about each other's motives shaped conflict between us? Where do we need to stop assigning motives and start asking questions?
- What is one way your spouse's reputation has been slandered — by others or even in your own mind — and how can you become their fierce defender this week?
Deuteronomy 19:16-19
If a malicious witness arises to accuse a person of wrongdoing, then both parties to the dispute shall appear before the LORD, before the priests and the judges who are in office in those days. The judges shall inquire diligently, and if the witness is a false witness and has accused his brother falsely, then you shall do to him as he intended to do to his brother. So you shall purge the evil from your midst.
Why this verse: This passage establishes the biblical standard for handling slander: rigorous investigation, severe penalty equal to the crime falsely alleged, and the removal of the accuser from the community. It is the textual spine of the sermon's claim that false witness is not a minor infraction but a grave evil worthy of judgment.
5-day reading plan
This week we trace the gravity of false witness from Satan's first lie in Eden through the law's severe remedy, learning to discern slander in every forum and cling to Christ's promise of a world where lies are finally destroyed.
Satan's question—'Did God really say?'—was the first lie ever told, and it worked by slandering God's character and motives. Every sin since has followed the same pattern: believe the lie about who God is, and you will disobey His word. We are still, in every temptation, being offered Satan's slander wrapped in doubt.
Solomon does not exaggerate: a good name is worth more than silver or gold because it is the currency of trust in every relationship, church, and community. When a slanderer steals someone's reputation, they have taken something no amount of money can recover. This is why the law treated false witness with such severity.
The command not to pervert justice and not to stand idle when a neighbor's blood is at stake is given in the same breath as the prohibition against going about spreading slander. The church, the workplace, the dinner table—these are courts too, and we are judges. Our bias, our carelessness, our eagerness to spread a juicy story, all function as corrupting influences on justice.
David's vow—'Whoever slanders his neighbor in secret, him will I put to silence'—shows that even a king of Israel understood the seriousness of false witness. The consequence was not a gentle conversation but removal from the king's household. We live as though slander is a minor vice; Scripture treats it as a structural threat to the community God is building.
Even as false witnesses were testifying against Jesus—their slander securing His death—He prayed, 'Father, forgive them.' Christ's cross did not vindicate the slanderers; it secured forgiveness for those who repent of slander and faith in Him. On that coming day when lies are erased from creation, the slanderer will either be forgiven in Christ or will stand alone before the God who knows every word ever spoken.
About the church
Crawler & AI-search policy · view robots.txt and llms.txt
This sermon page is intentionally optimized for search engines and AI assistants. We've opted into being crawled by both. The crawler-config files at the domain root:
/robots.txt
User-agent: * Allow: / User-agent: GPTBot Allow: / User-agent: ClaudeBot Allow: / User-agent: Google-Extended Allow: / User-agent: PerplexityBot Allow: / Sitemap: https://sermonsteward.com/sitemap.xml
/llms.txt
# Providence Community Church A church preaching expository sermons through the books of the Bible. ## Sermons - [Are Legalism and Licentiousness Really Equal Threats? (2024-10-09)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2024/10/are-legalism-and-licentiousness-really-equal-threats) - [Treasuring God (1 Peter 1:8-9, 2024-10-09)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2024/10/treasuring-god) - [Thou Shall Not Steal (2024-10-13)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2024/10/thou-shall-not-steal) - [When a Snake Takes the Stand (Exodus 20:16; Deuteronomy 19:15-21, 2024-10-20)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2024/10/when-a-snake-takes-the-stand) ## About - [About the church](/about) - [Plan a visit](/visit)
The page itself ships with Schema.org Article + Church markup (with real geo coordinates), Open Graph + Twitter cards for share previews, and a canonical URL. Transcripts are server-rendered HTML — no JS dependency for the readable body.