Community Group Conscience

September 5, 2023 Pastor Chris Oswald

Audio coming soon

—

Thesis The subjectivity of the Christian life — conscience, promptings, callings — becomes a terror when not anchored to the objective gospel, but when the heart is settled on Christ's sufficient payment, subjectivity becomes an invitation rather than a threat.

Series

—

Type

Topical

Tone

pastoraldidactic

Method

applicatorycanonical

What's in this sermon

The shape of the argument

12 units across exposition, application, illustration, theological claim, and conclusion. The pastor's argument is built from these moving parts.

Pastoral correction · unit #10

"The unit provides concrete discussion prompts for community groups: bring scripture on conscience, share experiences of conscience dominating the gospel, compare conscience before and after salvation. The goal is mutual encouragement in gospel objectivity and recognition that past struggles with subjectivity likely stemmed from insufficient gospel settledness rather than subjectivity itself."

Doctrinal loci· 2 surfaced

Sanctification · 11 Christology · 1

Bible citations· 3

Romans 7 | Proverbs (general reference) | 1 Corinthians 14

Illustrations· 4

The Anchored Boat analogy · unit #1 — The unit introduces the central analogy of the sermon: a boat tied to a pier. The pier represents the objective gospel; the boat represents the subjective experiences, promptings, and movements of the Christian life. The analogy establishes that subjectivity has legitimate room to move, but only within the bounds set by its anchor.
The Tyranny of Subjectivity personal story · unit #3 — Oswald narrates his own experience of living under the tyranny of subjectivity in his late teens and early twenties — obsessively seeking God's guidance on every decision, including trivial matters like lunch. The illustration demonstrates what happens when subjective conscience dominates without being anchored to gospel assurance.
The Regiment Solution personal story · unit #4 — The illustration continues: Oswald responded to the tyranny of subjectivity by swinging to the opposite extreme — eliminating all subjective elements and living a purely regimented, objective Christian life. He experienced relief from the anxiety but not joy or closeness with God. The unit reveals that eliminating subjectivity is not the solution.
The Flower Pot Prompting personal story · unit #7 — The unit illustrates gospel-anchored subjectivity through a concrete personal story. Oswald sensed a prompting to buy a flower pot for his wife, declined the prompting without anxiety, and later discovered it might have been from God when the pot was needed. The story demonstrates calm discernment of promptings without viewing them as salvation tests. The believer can miss an invitation without falling into terror.

Theological claims· 5

The Christian life contains both an objective element (the Word and gospel declaring justification in Christ) and a subjective element (conscience, promptings, callings). unit #2
The tyranny of subjectivity is not solved by eliminating subjectivity but by settling the heart on the gospel — the difference is not between knowing the gospel intellectually and not knowing it, but between the mind understanding it and the heart being calmed by it. unit #5
When anchored to the perfect sacrifice of Christ, the subjectivity of the Christian life — promptings, callings, conscience — is no longer a terror but something that can be examined calmly and thoughtfully. unit #6
God does not judge disobedience to a subjective prompting with the same severity as disobedience to His revealed Word — promptings are invitations to participate, not commands carrying the authority of Scripture. unit #8
Believers who lack gospel confidence have no sense of proportion between God's declared Word and subjective elements — the path to healthy subjectivity is doubling down on the certainty of the gospel, not eliminating conscience. unit #9

Quotations· 3

"Paul had a real healthy awareness of his own sinful condition. Let me ask, whose sin are you aware of the most in your life currently? Is it a friend's sin, or maybe a child's sin, or even a spouse's sin? Well, if we are thinking rightly, if we are thinking in line with the gospel, all the sin of others should pale in comparison to the knowledge of our own sin. Truly, we should not think, 'Boy, I wish someone's over here right now to listen to this message.' Well, I've been there. But we should listen humbly and acknowledge that God is addressing us through His Word, and that we ourselves, that I myself, need to hear this message more than anyone else. Truly, we must be a humble people. Paul was a humble man because Paul was a gospel man. He was so assured, he was so assured of God's love for him in Christ, of his being counted righteous in Christ, of his adoption by the Father, that he could look at himself honestly and admit his sin freely because he knew that God loved him." — Dub Cohen (unit #0)

"Knox knew that the Father was not angry with him for Christ's sake, and he knew his present corruption." — John Knox biographer (unit #5)

"That corruption was a grief to him, but not a threat to him." — John Knox biographer (unit #5)

Read it

Full transcript

19,677 characters 12 units ~22 min reading time

0 · The introduction establishes the sermon's connection to a previous message on gospel-centered humility and announces the purpose: to provide discussion material for community groups on the subjective side of the Christian life, particularly conscience

Paul had a real healthy awareness of his own sinful condition. Let me ask, whose sin are you aware of the most in your life currently? Is it a friend's sin, or maybe a child's sin, or even a spouse's sin? Well, if we are thinking rightly, if we are thinking in line with the gospel, all the sin of others should pale in comparison to the knowledge of our own sin. Truly, we should not think, 'Boy, I wish someone's over here right now to listen to this message.' Well, I've been there. But we should listen humbly and acknowledge that God is addressing us through His Word, and that we ourselves, that I myself, need to hear this message more than anyone else. Truly, we must be a humble people. Paul was a humble man because Paul was a gospel man. He was so assured, he was so assured of God's love for him in Christ, of his being counted righteous in Christ, of his adoption by the Father, that he could look at himself honestly and admit his sin freely because he knew that God loved him. That was the mighty Dub Cohen preaching 2 weeks ago, 7 Marks of a Gospel-Centered Culture, discussing the issue of humility, which I believe, especially in the way that he described it, discussed it, ties into our conversation from the sermon 2 days ago, dealing specifically with the conscience. And issues of more about the subjective side of the Christian life. So I thought to, to serve up a good kind of podcast to give you fodder for your conversations with community groups that meet tomorrow evening, Wednesday, September 6th.

1 · The unit introduces the central analogy of the sermon: a boat tied to a pier

I thought I would just kind of give you a bit of a, of a, of a thought process to work through. In your community groups about some of the subjectivity within the Christian life. Now, what do I mean about subjectivity? Well, I think that the way to— I think there are different formulas that work for this, different ways of talking about it. But one of the things that I can imagine is, suppose you've got a pretty awesome piece of property, and on that property there's a really proper boat dock. Now, this isn't just a dock that floats on the water, but it's more like a pier. It goes out into the lake quite a ways, and there's posts that are deep into the ground and so on and so forth. Now, that's a very objective thing. It's not moving. It's a very static thing. But now you tie a nice little sweet little rowboat or something to that. And you, you know, you get a pretty long and strong rope. And so if you're in the boat, there is movement, there is a bit of unpredictability. You know, the waves come, the wind comes, just little different nuances, your movement, your position in the boat. There's all these things that are affecting sort of where you go. But you're only going to go in a certain number of possible directions because you are indeed anchored to this awesome pier or dock.

2 · The unit defines the objective and subjective elements of the Christian life

Well, the Christian life is really, I think, if we just take the biblical data without trying to overly harmonize it, you know, sometimes we do that. If we take the biblical data, I think we just wind up with this idea that there is an objective element to the Christian life, and that is the Word of God disclosing the gospel of God. The Word of God disclosing the gospel of God. And the gospel of God is essentially that you are right with him in Christ because the payment that Christ offered on the cross was more than enough to pay for your many sins, both past, present, and future. That's the objectivity of the Christian life. The subjectivity is sort of promptings, feelings of conscience, maybe particular callings to do particular things or go particular places, sort of this sort of subjectivity.

3 · Oswald narrates his own experience of living under the tyranny of subjectivity in his late teens and early twenties — obsessively seeking God's guidance on every decision, including trivial matters like lunch

Now, A lot of people have experience similar to mine. And that is that they lived a subjective Christianity without really thoroughly having clarity and being convinced of the objective layers. So hold on one second, coffee break. It's coffee sip time. It's getting cold. I need to hit this real quick. Okay, thank you. So, so my experience would be that, and what's funny about my experience is that I didn't grow up in an overly charismatic environment. I mean, I had a lot of charismatic tendencies, but I myself didn't. That wasn't my denominational environment. What else? The gospel was relatively accurately portrayed. But I would not say emphasized, and that'll come up later. So anyway, I get into kind of my thinking years, my early, my late teens and early 20s. And I am just burdened by the subjectivities of the Christian life. I'm really getting to the point where I'm like, I'm wondering, I'm trying to pray through everything. And I'm trying to like ask God, like what I should have for lunch. Like, I think I probably actually— it wouldn't have lasted long, but I think I probably even got to that point. And so I'm just really in this, you know, what I've referred to on Sunday as the tyranny of subjectivity. And it's an extremely unpleasant situation. It's not really producing any good fruit. And I don't feel like I'm even, like, understanding God, really. You know, it was a very self-centered, introspective approach to the Christian life.

4 · The illustration continues: Oswald responded to the tyranny of subjectivity by swinging to the opposite extreme — eliminating all subjective elements and living a purely regimented, objective Christian life

And so my, my, what I decided to do, I think I actually kind of did consciously decide to do this to some extent, is to just stop all the subjective nonsense and just live a very regimented, ordered life. Looking back, And I'm going to explain why I don't think that was a mistake. I think that it was the right prescription, but then needed to be removed at some point. And that would be the mistake is just like, how long did you let this prescription exist? So I eventually stopped doing those things. And I didn't see— I saw some relief, but I really didn't see a lot more joy. I didn't, I didn't see like, I didn't see like a lot more closeness with the Lord and so on. So to be clear, I'm talking like I was in all, I was in subjective land and I was like, you know what, like this isn't working. Let's just stop this. Let's just go all regiment, all objective. Okay. So I did that. It's like, I'm doing that now and I don't feel as bad all the time, but I, don't necessarily either feel joy. And, you know, time goes by.

5 · The unit makes the central theological claim of the sermon

And one of the benefits of just like trying to serve others and be a blessing to others is you're just learning all the time, and you're kind of forced back into the Word constantly. And so I was growing, growing in the Lord. And eventually, I realized that the problem wasn't subjectivity or objectivity, per se. The problem certainly wasn't an overly subjective Christian life for me. The problem was, is I just didn't understand the gospel. I understood the gospel enough to be saved. I understood the gospel enough to know that it was Jesus, right? I got that. But I think I probably intellectually understood the gospel. For quite some time before my heart was utterly calmed with the gospel. And, of course, utterly is hyperbole. There are moments to this day where my heart is not appropriately calmed in the gospel. But there was a transfer, a transition that happened as I got older, where the gospel became just the bedrock, right? And now my experience is like, this is what I'm trying to invite you into as well. It's like, okay, now I can take this boat out and tie it to the objective mooring or anchor of the gospel. And the subjectivity of the wind and the waves and so on, that still matters to some extent, the callings, the the promptings of the Holy Spirit, so forth. That all matters to some extent, but it's a completely different experience when you're moored to something that doesn't move. It's a completely different experience. And so now I look back at all of that subjectivity and thinking that was the problem, and I realized that wasn't the problem. The problem was just that, you know, there is some wiggle room and some subjectivity and room for conscience and things like that within the Christian life. You need those things. Just a clear, honest reading of the Bible shows that those things are a part of the Christian life. And people try to throw that out because it's so hard. It's like, well, what's going on there? Well, for me, and I think this is relatively common, it isn't a problem. The subjectivity isn't a problem. It's simply disproportionate because— not because I've made it more than it should be, but because I haven't made the gospel as much as it is. I think that when you talk to people who begin to see the weightiness of the idea that God loved you even when you were in sin and offered himself up for you to be tortured and to pay for all of your sins, past, present, and future, so that you can live in eternity with him as his child, I think that's something that many of us could say, articulate, There is a difference, though, between the mind understanding that enough to speak it, and a heart that has settled on it. And so I will sometimes, and I think maybe a few people might have picked up on what they felt like was a bit of doublespeak from me yesterday, because in personal counseling times, I will tell some people, you need to stop. Living in the subjectivity for now. I try to always remember to say for now. But what I'm really getting at when I encourage someone to do that is that what I really am seeing is your heart isn't settled on the gospel. And you need to learn to walk before you can run. You need to learn to tie that boat down to this thing that won't move. You need to fill your heart full of the joy and glory that God has chosen you apart from any merit of your own. And that's really when Dove was talking about Paul's humility, and he talked about this idea that he could be honest about himself, even in a Romans 7 level way. He could be honest about himself, acknowledge his own sin, because he knew that God loved him in Jesus Christ. And Dove's comments reminded me of something I'd read in a Knox biography, a John Knox biography. And I know I read this to y'all in a sermon, probably sometime this summer. I just can't remember which. But there's a section in the biography where Knox is kind of, you know, it's discussed, you know, Knox being hard on himself, so to speak. And he's not really being hard on himself, he's just being honest. Like, I sinned here, I sinned there, and so on and so forth. And the biographer writes so astutely, Knox knew that the Father was not angry with him for Christ's sake, and he knew his present corruption. So he knew two things. He knew that in Christ, the Father was not angry with him, and he also knew that he was still a sinner. And then the next line in the biography, that corruption was a grief to him, but not a threat to him. That corruption was a grief to him, but not a threat to him.

6 · The unit extends the boat-and-pier analogy to show what gospel-anchored subjectivity looks like in practice

And friends, this is where, this is where our subjectivity gets anchored. It gets anchored to the perfect, more than enough, hyper-abounding sacrifice of Jesus Christ. On our behalf. That's, that's the anchor, the sure anchor of our soul. And then, you know, it's like, okay, now I'm anchored. Does it mean that there's no unpredictability? Does it mean there's no movement of the Spirit, the rock, the wind of God? Well, no, no, no, no, no, no, there is. But I'm anchored. And so now suddenly the movement, the subjectivity of the wind and the waves and the, you know, my weight in the boat in this place or that place and so on, the subjectivity isn't a terror to me. It's something I can look at in a bit of a dispassionate way and say, well, let me think about what's happening here. Let me think about this prompting or that prompting. And then let me kind of consider what I should do with it, whether I should trust it or not, whether, you know, so on and so forth.

7 · The unit illustrates gospel-anchored subjectivity through a concrete personal story

Let me give you an example. I went to Home Depot yesterday to pick up a few things. It was relatively early in the morning, and I was walking through, through the plant section on the way to somewhere else. And I saw a flower pot that was on sale. It was a good price. I felt in that moment what I sensed might have been a prompting from the Holy Spirit to buy that flower pot and give it to my wife. She doesn't need a flower pot. And so I thought, it's okay. Now, because to a larger extent than a long time in my life, the gospel has sort of settled me. I didn't view that as a test of my salvation. I viewed that as an invitation at the most. First of all, I viewed it as highly possible that I was just making things up in my head. And I also viewed it, if it was from God, as an invitation at the most to just participate in something. Certainly there was no sin associated with this. And I kind of just passed. I just was like, okay, no, She doesn't need that. You know, all of her plants have pots. And I even went so far as to think, well, should I get her a plant? I looked at the plants like, no, you know, these are all having good lives here. They don't need to be brought home to my house to die. Sorry, I couldn't resist. Anyway, so I passed. I just said, no, I'm not going to buy the pot. So we, you know, I get home and we're going throughout our day and all the kids come over, you know, we're gonna have Labor Day dinner together. And the old Jared tips over a flower pot on the floor next to him and it cracks and breaks into like 12 pieces. And now Angela's scrambling to look for a pot. Well, I just laughed. I didn't, I just thought, man, I would have been so cool. I would have been so cool if I had come home, you know, at 10 AM and been like, hey, I got you this flower pot. She'd be like, why did you get this for me? Like, I don't need a flower pot, which is totally what she would do. And then like 4 hours later, Jared breaks the flower pot. And I'm like, I knew. But I didn't take the Lord up on that opportunity. I wasn't even sure it was him. So you see what I'm saying? Like, and that's a small thing, I know. But there are even times now when I know I missed something. And what I missed was an invitation. And I want to get better at those things.

8 · The unit establishes a critical theological boundary: God does not judge disobedience to subjective promptings with the same severity as disobedience to His revealed Word

But I want to conclude this introduction of this subject to— well, I've got one more, like, one more thing to share. And then I'm going to throw out some questions that you could use for community group. I'm still laughing at my Well, anyway, I want to be clear about something. There is no just God who exists who would judge you for disobeying a prompting at the same level as he would judge you for disobeying his word. So, a bit of a complicated way of talking about this. I'll say it again. There is no just God who exists that would punish you for disobeying a prompting at the same level as he would punish you. Punish isn't really the right word. Give me one more try. There is no just God who would judge you with the same passion or the same level of severity for disobeying a prompting as he would for disobeying his word. And let me tell you how I know that. God tells you constantly in Proverbs to not trust in your own senses. Right? And then, and also like, this sense of like, don't follow your heart is all over God's word. And then you could go into 1 Corinthians, was it 14? Where prophets, which were a revelatory office to some degree, of some extent, we could talk about that one day. In more detail. But, you know, they were people who would stand up and say, I think I have a word from the Lord, and so on. And what is that enjoined with in Paul's teaching? Test it, right? There's literally no case to be made that the God of the universe, who has revealed himself to us through Christ and his word, is looking at you and looking at me and saying, Chris, you know, I told you to buy that flower pot. You did not, and you sinned. I think that what we're looking at here is, Chris, I invited you to do that. You were distrusting of your own capacity for nonsense and creating nonsense in your own head, which I get and appreciate. Let's keep working on that. And if nothing else, you'll have a good story to tell on your next podcast.

9 · The unit identifies the core problem in those who live under the tyranny of subjectivity: they lack a sense of proportion between God's declared Word and subjective elements like promptings and conscience

See, this is the big part of the low gospel confidence people. They have no sense of proportion over the difference between God's declared word and inference, observation, ideas, promptings, conscience, and so on and so forth. And so when I'm inviting folks back into a world that has the conscience as a voice in their understanding or their walk with Christ. I want to be clear, the way you get there is by doubling down on the certainty that Jesus has paid it all and that you are not a boat roaming all over the seas according to the winds and waves, but that you have a sure anchor of the soul And then, as a consequence of that, the movement that is sort of up in the air about, like, well, how is the next moment going to go? Well, you don't know. There is a subjectivity to the Christian life, but it's anchored. It's anchored to the truth that Jesus Christ is God, that he came and offered himself as a payment, not only for your sins, but to redeem you from the race of Adam, and adopt you into the family of God. And he has a plan for you to turn all things to your good, to help you to be more like Jesus, which is the best thing that could ever happen to you. And he has a plan to pull you into eternal glory, where you will be completely free from sin and created to enjoy God forever as his child. That's the anchor. The more you believe that, the safer and more joy you'll experience, the more safety and joy you'll experience in exploring the subjective elements. That's how I would describe it.

10 · The unit provides concrete discussion prompts for community groups: bring scripture on conscience, share experiences of conscience dominating the gospel, compare conscience before and after salvation

So for your community group discussions, here's what I would encourage you to do. I'd encourage you to possibly someone could maybe come with a printout of a number of verses that talk about the conscience. That'd be kind of a cool contribution. Maybe somebody else could think of a time when they've experienced something similar to what I'm describing. I do think that this is fairly common, that the conscience kind of maybe sometimes gets ahead of the gospel. So maybe talk about that. I wonder if someone could describe or share a time, an experience with their conscience before they were saved and after they were saved. My wife and I were joking about this young man that we know who, he just seemed way cooler before he got saved. He just wasn't as riddled. He wasn't as riddled with questions and humility. Now he was just full of himself. And in some ways, it was like, externally, he appeared cooler than he is now. So maybe somebody can talk about their experience with the conscience before they were saved. And yeah, I think that the best thing that we could achieve as a consequence of this community group is to sort of encourage one another in the objectivity of the gospel and see that, yes, there is some subjectivity in the Christian life. And if you've had bad experiences with subjectivity before, I doubt it's because of the subjectivity itself. It's because the gospel just wasn't what it needed to be for you yet.

11 · The conclusion synthesizes Oswald's journey: as the gospel's gravitational pull increased, he experienced God's invitation to return to the subjective elements he had once abandoned

And so I think the proper way for me to evaluate some of my past experiences would be to say that I have continued to grow in the gospel. It has continued, it has increased its gravitational pull on me. Its mass has become bigger in my solar system. It's the thing now. And as that has happened, I've felt an invitation and a call from the Lord. It's like, hey, man, let's go back to some of these things, this walk that we had before. I've given you the ability to stand firm in the gospel. To a larger extent than you had ever before. Now let's go back and talk about these, these other issues. Hope that's helpful. I apologize for it being a little extra long, but hope that's helpful. And may God bless your time in community groups tomorrow evening, if you're on a Wednesday community group, and Sunday from this Sunday, if you're on the Sunday group.

Where this fits

Recent preaching context

The three sermons immediately preceding this one in the preaching schedule.

Aug 22, 2022

Patient Kindness

Love requires both patience and kindness working inseparably together, with patience serving as the delivery system for intentional, costly kindness even toward those who test us.

1 Corinthians 13:4

Jan 21, 2023

Rely on God's Spirit, Rehearse God's Sovereignty

Christians overcome fear and embrace hardship not by eliminating fear or relying on human strength, but by depending on the Holy Spirit to illuminate God's sovereignty, particularly His sovereignty in salvation, which establishes that God has already done the hardest thing and can be trusted with all lesser trials.

Jun 4, 2023

Blessed Are the Poor in Spirit

True spiritual flourishing begins with felt spiritual poverty—a day-to-day desperate dependency on God that shatters the delusion of self-sufficiency and establishes us in the reality of our helpless need for Christ in every moment.

Matthew 5:3

September 5 · This sermon

Community Group Conscience

The subjectivity of the Christian life — conscience, promptings, callings — becomes a terror when not anchored to the objective gospel, but when the heart is settled on Christ's sufficient payment, subjectivity becomes an invitation rather than a threat.

Take it further

Discuss · apply · pray

Small groups

6 discussion questions

Chris distinguished between the objective element of the Christian life (the gospel's declaration of justification in Christ) and the subjec…

Daily readings

5-day reading plan

This week we anchor the subjectivity of the Christian life—conscience, promptings, callings—to the objective reality of Christ's finished work, moving from the gospel's certainty through the Spirit's invitation to our glad response.

Prayer

A Heart Settled on the Gospel

Father, we come before you in awe of your character — that you are a God of both objective certainty and intimate knowing, who speaks to us…

Family table

When Your Heart Feels Two Ways

This prompt invites kids to name a real experience of feeling torn between what they know is right and what they want to do—the internal con…

Couples

Gospel Confidence & Subjective Freedom

What aspect of the sermon most settled your heart — the idea that Christ's payment covers all our sin, or the freedom to explore the Spirit'…

Memorize

Romans 7:24-25

This verse encapsulates the sermon's central tension — the Christian's honest struggle with subjectivity (the wretchedness Paul describes) resolved entirely by gospel certainty (deliverance through Christ). It anchors subjective experience to objective redemption, showing that the path to freedom from the tyranny of subjectivity is not elimination of struggle but settlement of the heart on Christ's finished work.

Memory verse this week

Romans 7:24-25

Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!

Why this verse: This verse encapsulates the sermon's central tension — the Christian's honest struggle with subjectivity (the wretchedness Paul describes) resolved entirely by gospel certainty (deliverance through Christ). It anchors subjective experience to objective redemption, showing that the path to freedom from the tyranny of subjectivity is not elimination of struggle but settlement of the heart on Christ's finished work.

Draft · pending review

Small-group discussion

6 questions for your group this week

Chris distinguished between the objective element of the Christian life (the gospel's declaration of justification in Christ) and the subjective element (conscience, promptings, callings). What made this distinction important for understanding the sermon's main point?

→ Can you think of a specific moment this week when you faced a subjective prompting or felt your conscience stir about something? What was that experience like?
The sermon argues that many believers experience 'the tyranny of subjectivity.' What does that tyranny look like, and how is it different from simply making a mistake or falling short?

Romans 7

→ When have you felt crushed or terrorized by uncertainty about what God wanted from you, rather than simply uncertain?
According to the sermon, the solution to the tyranny of subjectivity is not to eliminate conscience and promptings but to anchor them to something else. What is that anchor, and why does settling your heart on it change how you experience subjectivity?

→ What's the difference between knowing the gospel in your head and having your heart calmed by it? How have you experienced that difference?
The sermon claims that God does not judge disobedience to a subjective prompting with the same severity as disobedience to His revealed Word. Why does understanding this distinction matter for how we live out our faith?

1 Corinthians 14

→ How does this perspective change the way you think about a prompting you're currently uncertain about—either one you're pursuing or one you're wrestling with?
When your heart is genuinely settled on Christ's sufficient payment for all your sin, how does that foundation enable you to examine your own conscience and the Spirit's promptings without fear?
What would it look like, practically, for you to 'double down on the certainty of the gospel' this week when you encounter a subjective prompting or feel your conscience stirring about something?

Proverbs

→ Who in your community group could help hold you accountable to that commitment?

Draft · pending review

Daily readings · Monday–Friday

5-day reading plan

Monday Romans 7

Paul's wrestling in Romans 7 shows the believer's honest inner turmoil—the law awakens sin's presence, yet we are not condemned. This interior struggle is not evidence of God's absence but the normal terrain of the Christian who knows both law and grace. The objective truth that we are justified in Christ (Romans 7:25) does not erase the subjective reality of ongoing conflict; rather, it frames that conflict as the space where the Spirit works.

Tuesday Romans 7

Paul cries out, "Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me?" and answers immediately with the gospel: "Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord" (Romans 7:24-25). The deliverance is not intellectual dismissal of struggle but a heart-settled recognition that Christ has already paid the price for every sin—past, present, and future. When we are calm in our hearts about the sufficiency of His payment, the subjective turmoil of conscience becomes a space we can examine honestly rather than a verdict we must flee.

Wednesday 1 Corinthians 14

Paul instructs the Corinthian church to "desire earnestly to prophesy" and to "let two or three prophets speak" while "the others pass judgment" (1 Corinthians 14:29-32). The Spirit's promptings are to be neither blindly obeyed nor fearfully rejected, but weighed and tested with calm discernment. This is only possible when the community's hearts are settled on the gospel—when we know we are loved and justified, we can evaluate subjective elements without the terror that we might miss God or lose His approval.

Thursday Proverbs (general reference)

Proverbs consistently invites us into discernment and wisdom rather than commanding absolute obedience to internal impulse. The wisdom literature teaches us to test, to consider, to seek counsel—acknowledging that promptings and callings are real but different in character from the binding authority of God's Word. When we understand this proportion, we are freed from the false guilt of not perfectly discerning every whisper of the Spirit, and we can approach our subjective experience with the maturity God intends.

Friday 1 Corinthians 14

Paul grounds his instruction on spiritual gifts and prophecy in love and the building up of the church (1 Corinthians 14:1-5)—the criterion is not anxiety or perfectionism but the gospel's freedom to pursue what edifies the body. When our hearts are rooted in the gospel, we no longer approach conscience and promptings as a minefield where one wrong step forfeits God's love; instead, we pursue them as an invitation to participate in God's redemptive work. The stronger our gospel confidence, the more freely and humbly we can engage the Spirit's work in our lives and in one another.

Draft · pending review

Pray together this week

A Heart Settled on the Gospel

Father, we come before you in awe of your character — that you are a God of both objective certainty and intimate knowing, who speaks to us through your revealed Word and through the promptings of your Spirit. We confess that we often live in terror of subjectivity, afraid that the movements of conscience within us will condemn us, uncertain whether we are hearing your voice or our own fears. We acknowledge our weakness: we understand the gospel in our minds, yet our hearts remain unsettled, and we find ourselves paralyzed by the fear that we are missing your will or failing to obey your promptings (Romans 7).

Yet in the gospel we have immeasurable peace. Christ's perfect sacrifice has fully covered all our sin — past, present, and future — and his payment is sufficient and complete. We are declared righteous not because our conscience is clean or because we have perfectly discerned your prompting, but because Jesus has borne the full weight of God's judgment in our place. The gospel does not eliminate our need to listen and respond; rather, it frees us from the terror that attends our listening.

We ask you, Holy Spirit, to settle our hearts on this gospel reality. Grant us the grace to distinguish between your declared Word — which carries your full authority and demands our obedience — and the promptings of conscience and calling, which are invitations to participate in your work rather than commands that carry the weight of salvation itself. Help us to examine our promptings calmly and thoughtfully, without the panic that comes from an unsettled heart. As we navigate the subjectivity of Christian life together in this community, give us wisdom to discern your voice, courage to follow where you lead, and the deep peace that comes from knowing we are already loved and accepted in Christ.

To you alone be the glory, Father, for anchoring our souls to the unshakable reality of the gospel, and for inviting us into the safe and joyful pursuit of your will.

Draft · pending review

Sunday-evening family table

When Your Heart Feels Two Ways

For the parent

This prompt invites kids to name a real experience of feeling torn between what they know is right and what they want to do—the internal conflict the sermon called 'subjectivity.' The goal is to help them see that feeling conflicted isn't sin, and that knowing Jesus paid for everything gives us courage to be honest about those feelings instead of hiding them.

Tell about a time when you felt pulled in two different directions—like part of you wanted to do one thing, but another part of you knew you should do something else. What was that feeling like? And here's the big question: did knowing that Jesus already paid for your sins make it easier or harder to be honest about what you were feeling?

works for ages 7+ — younger kids may need help naming the feeling, but can absolutely relate to the experience

Draft · pending review

Couples · three questions over coffee

Gospel Confidence & Subjective Freedom

What aspect of the sermon most settled your heart — the idea that Christ's payment covers all our sin, or the freedom to explore the Spirit's promptings without terror?
Where do we tend to experience the tyranny of subjectivity together — in decisions, in conscience, in sensing God's call — and how might anchoring ourselves more deeply in the gospel change how we navigate those moments as a couple?
Is there a specific prompting or calling one of us senses right now that we could pray through together, asking God to give us both gospel confidence and wisdom to discern His invitation?

Draft · pending review

Where this was preached

About the church

Providence Community Church

Lenexa, KS
Sundays · 10:00 AM
About us · What we believe

Plan a visit →

Crawler & AI-search policy · view robots.txt and llms.txt

This sermon page is intentionally optimized for search engines and AI assistants. We've opted into being crawled by both. The crawler-config files at the domain root:

/robots.txt

User-agent: *
Allow: /

User-agent: GPTBot
Allow: /

User-agent: ClaudeBot
Allow: /

User-agent: Google-Extended
Allow: /

User-agent: PerplexityBot
Allow: /

Sitemap: https://sermonsteward.com/sitemap.xml

/llms.txt

# Providence Community Church

A church preaching expository sermons through the books of the Bible.

## Sermons
- [Patient Kindness (1 Corinthians 13:4, 2022-08-22)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2022/08/8222022)
- [Rely on God's Spirit, Rehearse God's Sovereignty (2023-01-21)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2023/01/rely-on-god-s-spirit-rehearse-god-s-sovereignty)
- [Blessed Are the Poor in Spirit (Matthew 5:3, 2023-06-04)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2023/06/blessed-are-the-poor-in-spirit)
- [Community Group Conscience (2023-09-05)](/ProvidenceLenexa/sermons/2023/09/community-group-conscience)

## About
- [About the church](/about)
- [Plan a visit](/visit)

The page itself ships with Schema.org Article + Church markup (with real geo coordinates), Open Graph + Twitter cards for share previews, and a canonical URL. Transcripts are server-rendered HTML — no JS dependency for the readable body.