The Two Voices on Your Shoulder

1 Samuel 25:1-44 December 7, 2025 Pastor Ricky Alcantar
Thesis Believers must choose daily to listen to the voice of wisdom embodied in Christ rather than the voice of folly, which leads to destruction.
Series
Type
Expository
Tone
didacticpastoralprophetic
Method
redemptive-historicalgrammatical-historicalapplicatory
What's in this sermon

The shape of the argument

26 units across exposition, application, illustration, theological claim, and conclusion. The pastor's argument is built from these moving parts.

Pastoral correction · unit #9
"The pastor applies the three marks of foolishness to contemporary media consumption, arguing that foolish voices in entertainment can influence believers to speak and act foolishly themselves."
Doctrinal loci· 10 surfaced
Sanctification · 10 Hamartiology · 6 Christology · 4 Ethics / Moral Theology · 4 Bibliology · 3 Ecclesiology · 3 Soteriology · 3 Providence / Sovereignty · 2 Theology Proper · 2 Anthropology · 1
Bible citations· 18
1 Samuel 25:1-3 | 1 Samuel 25:1 | Proverbs (book reference) | 1 Samuel 25:4-11 | Proverbs 26:12 | Proverbs 14:17 | Proverbs 29:11 | Psalms (general reference) | Proverbs 1:7 | 1 Samuel 25:12-13 | 1 Samuel 25:21-22 | 1 Samuel 25:24-31 | 1 Samuel 25:36-38 | Proverbs 1:32 | 1 Timothy 2:5-6 | 1 Samuel 25:40-43 | Hosea (book reference) | John 1:14
Illustrations· 2
  1. cultural reference · unit #2 — The pastor uses the cultural image of a devil and angel on opposing shoulders to introduce the sermon's theme of two competing voices offering counsel—a picture the congregation instantly recognizes from popular media.
  2. personal story · unit #10 — The pastor uses a personal story about his son mimicking the behavior of a television character to illustrate how consuming foolish voices shapes our own speech and actions.
Theological claims· 10
  1. The conflict between two voices offering counsel originates in Hebrew wisdom literature and manifests in 1 Samuel 25 through the characters of Nabal (the Fool) and Abigail (Lady Wisdom). unit #3
  2. The foolish voice is marked by pride that makes everything about oneself and by ungoverned emotion that reacts without restraint. unit #7
  3. The foolish voice is fundamentally godless, operating without any reference to the Lord or his ways. unit #8
  4. Foolishness begets foolishness—either through influence or through reactive imitation. unit #11
  5. Wisdom's voice is marked by concern for others rather than self-centered calculation. unit #16
  6. Wisdom's voice calls for governed response rather than ungoverned reaction to offense or injury. unit #17
  7. Wisdom's voice reinserts the reality of God and his ways into situations, transforming how we perceive conflict and our own obligations. unit #18
  8. Abigail's mediatorial intervention is a type fulfilled in Christ, who is the ultimate mediator between God and humanity deserving judgment. unit #22
  9. David's unfaithfulness as a husband creates a longing fulfilled only in Christ, who is the perfectly faithful husband to his bride, the church. unit #23
  10. Jesus Christ is the full expression of the voice of wisdom from 1 Samuel 25, embodying both truth and grace as mediator and faithful husband. unit #24
Read it

Full transcript

36,722 characters 26 units ~41 min reading time Listen instead →

0 · The pastor frames the sermon by orienting the congregation to the narrative moment—David's transition from Samuel's guidance to a crisis point—and establishes the two contrasting characters (Nabal the fool and Abigail the wise) who will embody the sermon's central tension

Well, with that, let's open our Bibles to First Samuel, chapter 25. And I'm actually going to read a slightly different text that we read at the top of this in order to set this passage up. Well, so we're going to be reading 1st Samuel, chapter 25, and I'm going to be reading verses one through three as we pick up the story. David is the anointed king of Israel, but he is not on the throne yet. Saul is still king. And we've seen this continued conflict, but now we're about to hit a crucial moment in the life of David. And that crucial moment begins in verse one. This is God's word. Now, Samuel died and. And all Israel assembled and mourned for him. And they buried him in his house at Ramah. And then David arose and went down to the wilderness of Paran. And there was a man in Maon whose business was in Carmel. The man was very rich. He had 3,000 sheep and a thousand goats. He was shearing his sheep in Carmel. Now, the name of the man was. Was Nabal. The name of his wife, Abigail. The woman was discerning and beautiful. But the man was harsh and badly behaved. He was a Calebite. This is God's word.

1 · The pastor prays for God's blessing on the preaching and hearing of Scripture, asking for physical strength and spiritual clarity

And Lord, I pray your blessing over the preaching and the hearing of your word. And Lord, I just pray very practically that my voice would hold out well that I may be able to explain the Bible and lead my brothers and sisters to see what you have for us today in the Word, in Jesus name. Amen.

2 · The pastor uses the cultural image of a devil and angel on opposing shoulders to introduce the sermon's theme of two competing voices offering counsel—a picture the congregation instantly recognizes from popular media

Well, if I describe a particular image, I bet you anything you're going to have a very vivid and particular picture that pops into your mind. Here's the image. A character in a story forced to make a decision where suddenly pops up on their shoulder a little red person brandishing a pitchfork with little horns, ready to give advice. Anybody see him? Anybody see that little guy? Okay. And then on the other shoulder pops into existence a contrastingly white robed character with a golden halo, also ready to give advice. Anybody see those? Where does that picture even come from? And I began. That was the question I began to ask this week. Where. Where did that picture enter my mind? Was it Bugs Bunny? Was it a movie? I've seen what you know where. And I've seen it so many times, it even still floats around in Internet culture. Or like, you'll see a meme of it. This person. This person. Here's the advice. Here's. And. And so finally, this is the stuff I do. This is the stuff I use the Internet for. I tried to find the origin of this in pop culture, and I traced it, I believe, to a 1938 short film, very influential, starring the character Donald Duck. Donald Duck is who we owe this image to. And essentially, in this little short, Donald Duck, who I thought he was an adult, but in this short, he has to go to school. He's got his books, like, in a little belt, and he's, like, going to school. But this character appears, this devilish character, and basically tells Donald, no, you should not go to church. You should sleep in. Don't go to school. You should waste time. And then the height of the Temptation of Donald Duck, this thing that you're like, oh, that's a bridge too far, is that the devilish character entices Donald Duck to smoke a corn cob pipe and go fishing instead of going to school. And I'm like, I guess this is what they were dealing with in 1938. A lot of, like, fifth graders with corn cob pipes in the schoolyard. And then you've got the angel, right, of course, who's like, no, you should wake up. You should go to school. You should learn. You should resist the temptation of corn cob pipes and so on.

3 · The pastor establishes the biblical-theological foundation for the sermon by connecting the pop culture image to Hebrew wisdom literature, showing that Nabal and Abigail function as archetypal characters (Fool and Lady Wisdom) counseling David at a critical juncture after Samuel's death

Now, of course, this image didn't just pop out into the 20th century. It goes further back. It goes all the way to Marlowe's Dr. Faustus, if you know that play, if you're a Shakespeare fan, to medieval morality plays, to church Father, even describing this conflict. But here's what I think. I think if you trace this concept of two voices counseling you, I think if you trace it all the way back, it actually originates here. In fact, more specifically, in Hebrew literature. And Hebrew literature would have these characters, characters that, like pop culture. Characters, for us are things like Lady Liberty and Uncle Sam. If I say Uncle Sam, he's like, boop. You got a picture of Uncle Sam, right? Well, in literature, in Hebrew literature and Hebrew culture, they had characters that were similar, that were meant to help instruct. And two of the characters that were most prominent, if you read the Book of Proverbs, you'll see them all over. The two characters are Lady Wisdom and Mr. Fool, Mr. Fool and Lady Wisdom, both calling out to the people and both calling out, saying, listen to me now. Surprisingly, these two characters make an appearance in the book of First Samuel, which is why it's amazing to see the way that the genres of the Bible intersect with one another. It's almost like the wisdom literature, for a second, jumps into the narrative of First Samuel. And we're set up because this woman, Abigail, is described as discerning and beautiful, like Lady Wisdom in the Book of Proverbs. And contrastingly, her husband is described. Well, his name is Nabal, which, if you have a little footnote in your Bible, like mine, if you look back, Nabal means what? Fool. Literally, his name is fool, which I got a lot of questions about his parents and what list of names they were looking at, but that's his name. Okay? And so here's what happens. We arrive in 1st Samuel at this critical moment where Samuel the prophet has died. Now, remember, Samuel the prophet has been the one guiding David and guiding Israel throughout the whole book up until this point. He's kind of the Jiminy Cricket, as it were, of the story. And yet now, in this crucial moment, that voice is gone. And all of a sudden, David is forced to choose what kind of path he's going to walk, what kind of king he's going to be. And it just so happens that he's thrown into a middle of a situation where two very different voices are calling out to him. The voice of the fool and the voice of Lady Wisdom.

4 · The pastor applies the narrative framework directly to the congregation, posing the sermon's central question as an immediate personal choice each listener must make

And so for David and for us, the main question today is this. Are you listening to Mr. Fool or Lady Wisdom today? Because we all have the same choice in front of us this week. Today, will you listen to Mr. Fool or Lady Wisdom?

5 · The pastor signals the sermon's three-part structure and introduces the first major section examining Nabal's foolish voice

We're going to look at this in three sections, three voices. The first voice is the voice of Mr. Fool.

Where this fits

Recent preaching context

The three sermons immediately preceding this one in the preaching schedule.

Nov 2, 2025
Where you fix your eyes—on your circumstances or on God—determines whether you steer your life into faithless disaster like Saul or courageous victory like Jonathan, and the gospel calls you not to be the hero but to follow Jesus, who is the true Jonathan leading us out of death into triumph.
1 Samuel 13-15
Nov 16, 2025
Christians cannot be the hero of their own story, but in Christ they can fight like David—motivated by God's glory, equipped with a plan, and dependent on the Lord—knowing that Jesus has already won the ultimate victory over the world, the flesh, and the devil.
1 Samuel 17
Nov 23, 2025
The path to jealousy or contentment is paved by how you respond to God's rule and your role, and only through Christ can jealous sinners find the contentment that trusts God's sovereignty and embraces their assigned place in his eternal purposes.
1 Samuel 18-20
December 7 · This sermon
The Two Voices on Your Shoulder
Believers must choose daily to listen to the voice of wisdom embodied in Christ rather than the voice of folly, which leads to destruction.
1 Samuel 25:1-44
Take it further

Discuss · apply · pray

Small-group discussion

6 questions for your group this week

  1. When you read through 1 Samuel 25:1-13, what specific words or actions reveal Nabal's character to you? What does his response to David's request tell us about what he values?
    1 Samuel 25:10-11
    → How does Nabal's pride and refusal to acknowledge David remind you of foolishness you've witnessed—or engaged in—when someone dismisses another person's legitimate need?
  2. David's reaction to Nabal's insult is to prepare for violence (verses 21-22). What does his language reveal about his emotional state in that moment? How is David beginning to sound like Nabal?
    1 Samuel 25:21-22
  3. Abigail enters the story as a voice of wisdom. Read her speech in verses 24-31. What does she ask David to consider that he wasn't considering in his anger? What does she remind him about God's character and his own calling?
    1 Samuel 25:24-31
    → How does Abigail's concern for others—including for Nabal's household and for David's future—stand in contrast to the self-centered focus we saw in both Nabal and David's rage?
  4. The sermon identifies Abigail as embodying the voice of wisdom from Proverbs. Based on what we see her do and say, how does her character reflect what Proverbs teaches about wisdom—particularly her self-control, her fear of the Lord, and her concern for David's wellbeing?
    Proverbs 14:17, Proverbs 29:11
  5. The sermon teaches that Jesus Christ is the ultimate fulfillment of Abigail's mediatorial role. How does the work Christ does for us—standing between us and the judgment we deserve—reshape how you understand your own need to receive wisdom rather than react in foolishness?
    1 Timothy 2:5-6
    → When you're tempted to respond to offense or hurt with your own angry, self-centered reaction, what would it look like to instead receive the wisdom and grace Christ offers you in that moment?
  6. This week, what specific voice—whether from media, relationships, or your own thoughts—will be counseling you toward foolishness? And how will you intentionally choose to listen to the voice of wisdom instead?
Draft · pending review
Daily readings · Monday–Friday

5-day reading plan

This week we learn to recognize and choose the voice of wisdom over the voice of folly—a daily battle that finds its ultimate resolution in Christ.

Monday Proverbs 1:7

The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge, but fools despise wisdom and instruction. This is the foundation: every voice we listen to either points us toward God or away from him. When we hear counsel that ignores God's ways entirely—that calculates only personal gain, reputation, or immediate satisfaction—we are listening to folly, no matter how confident or eloquent the voice.

Tuesday Proverbs 29:11

A fool gives full vent to his spirit, but a wise man quietly holds it back. Nabal's rage at David's servants and David's own murderous anger in response—both were reactions that destroyed restraint. Notice the contrast: wisdom doesn't deny emotion, it governs it. The question we face daily is whether our anger, our hurt, our offense will control us or whether we will, by God's grace, hold ourselves back from the destruction our feelings demand.

Wednesday Proverbs 14:17

A quick-tempered man does foolish things. David was about to become exactly what Nabal was—a man acting out of unbridled anger, about to massacre an entire household. This is how folly spreads: not always through teaching, but through contagion. When we consume media, relationships, and thought-patterns marked by ungoverned emotion and self-centeredness, we train ourselves to react foolishly to our own offenses. The pattern takes root in us.

Thursday Proverbs 26:12

Do you see a man wise in his own eyes? There is more hope for a fool than for him. Nabal refused the servants' respectful request because it was an affront to his dignity—he made David's reasonable need about himself. Pride is the engine of folly. It transforms a simple situation (a dispute over payment) into a referendum on personal honor. When we listen to voices that constantly reinforce our grievances and our importance, we are cultivating the soil in which folly grows.

Friday 1 Timothy 2:5-6

There is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, who gave himself as a ransom for all. Abigail stepped between David and destruction, offering herself as the mediator. But she was only a shadow of the true Mediator, who didn't just plead for us—he gave himself. When we listen to Christ's voice, we hear the wisdom that rescues us from our own foolishness, the grace that absorbs the judgment we deserve, and the faithful love that transforms us from the inside out. This is the voice we are invited to follow every day.

Draft · pending review
Pray together this week

Prayer: Choosing Wisdom's Voice

Father, we come before you in awe of your wisdom. You have given us your word, and in it the constant choice between two voices—the voice of folly that speaks pride, ungoverned emotion, and forgetfulness of you, and the voice of wisdom that calls us to self-control, concern for others, and fear of the Lord. We confess that we are quick to listen to foolishness. We consume media marked by self-centeredness and godlessness, and it trains our hearts and mouths to speak and act foolishly in return. We react to offense with our own offense, creating cycles of sin that lead only to relational death. We speak as though you are not watching, as though our words and choices do not matter in light of your kingdom.

Yet you have not left us without a mediator. Jesus Christ, your Son, is the fullness of wisdom incarnate. He interrupts our destructive paths with grace. He speaks truth marked by concern for our good, not his own advancement. He governs his response to our sin not with reactive anger but with sacrificial love. And by his death and resurrection, he stands between us and the judgment we deserve, calling us back to the Father's ways and making us his bride, forever faithful and loved.

We ask you, Father, to give us ears to hear wisdom's voice this week. When we are tempted to react in pride and ungoverned emotion, grant us the grace to pause and remember you. When we are tempted to consume what trains us in foolishness, give us the courage to turn away. And when we see others caught in cycles of folly, give us the wisdom and courage of Abigail—to speak truth marked by concern for their good and by the fear of the Lord. Make us more like Christ, the voice of wisdom we most need to hear. To him be the glory, forever. Amen.

Draft · pending review
Sunday-evening family table

Two Voices at the Table

For the parent

This sermon contrasts Nabal's foolish voice (selfish, reactive, godless) with Abigail's wise voice (others-focused, measured, God-centered). Use this prompt to help your family name which voice they're hearing in their own choices this week. Listen for moments where they recognize themselves in either character.

Ricky talked about two voices on our shoulder—one from Nabal the fool, one from Abigail the wise woman. Nabal's voice says 'I'm angry, I'm right, nobody else matters.' Abigail's voice says 'Let's stop and think about God and what matters most.' When you had a choice this week to listen to one of those voices, which one did you hear? And which one did you choose to follow?
works for ages 8+ — younger children can listen and share one example with help from a parent
Draft · pending review
Couples · three questions over coffee

Two Voices, One Choice

  1. Which voice—folly or wisdom—did you hear more clearly speaking into your own life this week, and what made it hard or easy to listen?
  2. Where in our marriage do we find ourselves reacting to each other's foolishness with foolishness of our own, and what would it look like to break that cycle by choosing wisdom together?
  3. How can we pray for each other this week to listen more carefully to Christ's voice—the voice of wisdom and grace—especially when we're tempted to speak or act in pride or anger?
Draft · pending review
Memory verse this week

1 Timothy 2:5-6

For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, who gave himself as a ransom for all, which is the testimony given at the proper time.

Why this verse: This verse captures the sermon's central claim that Jesus Christ is the ultimate fulfillment of Abigail's mediatorial role in 1 Samuel 25. Where Abigail intervened between David and destruction through wisdom and grace, Christ is the perfect mediator who stands between God and humanity, offering himself as ransom—the definitive answer to the choice between folly and wisdom that every believer faces daily.

Draft · pending review
Where this was preached

About the church

Cross of Grace Church
Plan a visit →
Crawler & AI-search policy · view robots.txt and llms.txt

This sermon page is intentionally optimized for search engines and AI assistants. We've opted into being crawled by both. The crawler-config files at the domain root:

/robots.txt
User-agent: *
Allow: /

User-agent: GPTBot
Allow: /

User-agent: ClaudeBot
Allow: /

User-agent: Google-Extended
Allow: /

User-agent: PerplexityBot
Allow: /

Sitemap: https://sermonsteward.com/sitemap.xml
/llms.txt
# Cross of Grace Church

A church preaching expository sermons through the books of the Bible.

## Sermons
- [You Steer With Your Eyes (1 Samuel 13-15, 2025-11-02)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/11/you-steer-with-your-eyes)
- [You're Not David (But You Should Be) (1 Samuel 17, 2025-11-16)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/11/you-re-not-david-but-you-should-be)
- [Jealous? (1 Samuel 18-20, 2025-11-23)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/11/jealous)
- [The Two Voices on Your Shoulder (1 Samuel 25:1-44, 2025-12-07)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/12/the-two-voices-on-your-shoulder)

## About
- [About the church](/about)
- [Plan a visit](/visit)

The page itself ships with Schema.org Article + Church markup, Open Graph + Twitter cards for share previews, and a canonical URL. Transcripts are server-rendered HTML — no JS dependency for the readable body.