Have You Looked at Your Heart?
Thesis Christians must attend to the condition of their hearts before God and trust His sovereign plan rather than relying on outward appearances or worldly wisdom.
The shape of the argument
52 units across exposition, application, illustration, theological claim, and conclusion. The pastor's argument is built from these moving parts.
- personal story · unit #1 — Personal story establishing what the pastor loved about football—the preparation, strategy, physical and mental demands, and camaraderie. Sets up the contrast to come.
- personal story · unit #2 — Extends the football illustration to introduce the problem: teammates who feigned injury all week, wore the jersey on game day, but couldn't perform because they hadn't done the actual preparation. The pastor's frustration sets up the disconnect between external appearance and internal reality.
- cultural reference · unit #41 — Introduces Stephen Curtis Chapman's song '2 B True' as an illustration of the necessity of living out what we profess to believe. The humorous framing (Chapman's 'foray into rap,' the mullet, the acoustic guitar) makes the illustration accessible and disarming before landing the serious point: it's about living out what's in our hearts.
- cultural reference · unit #42 — Continues the Chapman illustration by introducing the song's character Toby, whose neighbor is watching his behavior to see if his Christian profession is true. The pastor applies this directly: 'Do you have those people in your mind in your own life?' The illustration makes the stakes personal—our lives are watched, and hypocrisy is a barrier to belief.
- historical example · unit #44 — Returns to John Newton as the final illustration: a man who was objectively terrible, immune from no sin, yet apprehended by God's grace and transformed into an instrument of gospel proclamation. The illustration serves as a testimony to the power of God's heart-changing work and sets up the final application about not underestimating our own sin.
- God is not concerned with outward appearance alone but with the condition of the heart underneath. unit #3
- King Saul, though chosen for his worldly qualifications, lacked the spiritual qualities necessary to lead God's people. unit #10
- Samuel's grief reveals the misdirected hearts of both Israel (trusting worldly wisdom) and Saul (trusting himself and his own glory). unit #11
- God's provision of David is an act of sovereign seeing and providence—God sees the true king He desires and provides him as a gift to His people. unit #20
- The story of David's anointing teaches Israel that God can be trusted, that obedience is the path to care, and that they must attend to their hearts and trust God's plan. unit #23
- Conviction of sin is an ongoing grace that drives us to Christ, our all-sufficient physician—we must feel our malady to rightly prize our healer. unit #25
- Israel experiences both the cost of rejecting God's plan (through Saul's failure) and the mercy of God in bringing about His plan (through David's anointing) despite their failings. unit #26
- David, the unexpected shepherd king from Bethlehem and the line of Jesse, points forward to Jesus, the ultimate King and Savior. unit #29
- Jesus is the King of the universe who chose to come despite humanity's obsession with outward appearance, living perfectly and dying as a substitute to provide hope for us now and in eternity. unit #32
- Because Christ died for us despite seeing our failures, He covers our sin and actively reshapes us into His image. unit #33
- Attending to our hearts and trusting God's plan means using the biblical narratives to diagnose misdirection, recognize God's redirecting work, and rest in Christ's redemption. unit #46
- Awareness of our own depravity paired with confidence in Christ's infallibility leads not to despair but to hope, as we press on toward holiness under the care of the all-sufficient Savior. unit #48
"king Saul, chosen by the people because of his worldly qualifications, proved to have none of the spiritual qualities needed for leading God's people." — Richard Phillips (unit #10)
"My heart is like a country, but half subdued, where all things are in an unsettled state and mutinies and insurrections are daily happening. I hope I hate the rebels that disturbed the king's peace. I'm glad when I can point them out, lay hold of them, and bring them to him for justice. But they have many lurking holes, and sometimes they come disguised like friends so that I do not know them until their works discover them." — John Newton (unit #12)
"It's noteworthy. The word translated as provided is a form of the word ordinarily meaning to see. By his sovereign provision, God sees what his people in darkness cannot see. Just as later on we'll note that while man can only see appearances, God can see the heart. God sees the true king he has desired because God himself has provided this king. He is the product of God's providential oversight and God's gift to his people. The king whom God himself has Chosen." — Richard Phillips (unit #20)
"In comes David, fresh from the fields, unwashed and still smelling of the sheep. From what we learn later of his family life, his older brothers perhaps stood aloof as he drew near, looking down on the runt of their pack." — Dale Ralph Davis (unit #22)
"It's not enough just to read in the Bible about our remaining sin sin. It's not enough to hear from a preacher that our sin remains even after redemption. We are so totally depraved, Newton wrote, is a truth which no one ever truly learned by only being told it. We must discover our sin. We must feel our own sin, and it must shake us. And this feeling of our sin is a sure mark of the work of grace in Christ. There is all sufficient hope and forgiveness for a murderer who has killed 1,000 people. But there is no hope for any sinner who has not come face to face with the indwelling disease of sin." — Tony Reinke (unit #25)
"We must feel our malady before we rightly prize our physician and appeal to him as our all sufficient solution. The pain is a necessary grace given pain. Newton again, the Gospel affords no hope but to those whose hearts are contrite and broken by a conviction of sin. For while we feel not our malady, we cannot duly prize or rightly apply to the only physician." — John Newton (via Tony Reinke) (unit #25)
"your idol are revealed by where your money flows most freely." — Tim Keller (unit #36)
"John Newton's moral life prior to Christ had already sunk. He was a wicked and insubordinate young man with a profane tongue, flesh driven appetites and a stone cold heart. He had gambled his way into debt and dabbled in witchcraft. What is clear, Newton was immune from no sin. He delighted to lead others into temptation, later calling himself a ringleader in blasphemy and wickedness." — Tony Reinke (unit #44)
"the sum of my complaints amounts to this, that I am a sick sinner, diseased in every part but then, if he who is the infallible physician has undertaken my case, I shall not die, but live and declare the works of the Lord." — John Newton (unit #48)
"I could go on complaining. Newton wrote of a friend, wrote to a friend, but I check myself. I am vile indeed. But Jesus is full of grace and truth. He leads and guides, he feeds and guards, he restores and heals. He is an all sufficient Savior." — John Newton (unit #48)
Full transcript
0 · Frames the sermon by connecting last week's message (looking up to Christ) with this week's focus (looking into our hearts)
This week we'll be in 1st Samuel 16. Our text last week called us to look up to Christ. And this text will call us to look into our hearts, to attend to the status of our hearts before the Lord.
1 · Personal story establishing what the pastor loved about football—the preparation, strategy, physical and mental demands, and camaraderie
So as you open to 1 Samuel 16, I want to tell you about High School John. High School John played football. I loved playing football. I loved almost everything about football. I loved preparing during the week. I loved the contact. I loved the strategy. I loved the planning, the mental toughness, the physical tests that required. I loved the camaraderie, the brotherhood of the game. I loved getting to plan and prepare and execute each week. Shedding blood, sweat, and tears, quite literally together was something that I consistently looked forward to. I loved getting hit in the head, which might explain some things.
2 · Extends the football illustration to introduce the problem: teammates who feigned injury all week, wore the jersey on game day, but couldn't perform because they hadn't done the actual preparation
But the thing is, I found something really challenging. The one thing I found really challenging about football was the guys who always seemed to be hurt during the week who were like, ah, I just can't. I just don't think I can practice today. I don't think I can go today. I was like, oh, man. I think. And they're like kind of out there, like, working whatever it is out. And then they get to the game on. On Friday. They get to school on Friday wearing the jersey, and all of a sudden their injury was gone. Like, nothing was wrong. They were just walking around. Like they've been walking around with a limp all day, taped ankle, whatever. And they're just like, here I am, ready to play, had the jersey on, was all ready to go. And then the game would come and they'd sit on the bench and wonder why. And then, like, they get put in maybe in the fourth quarter, and then they wouldn't be good. And I just was frustrated with those dudes because I was like, you're not putting the work in. You're not. What are you doing?
3 · Draws the football analogy to its theological point: external appearance means nothing without internal preparation
The reality is they loved getting suited up. They loved being on the sideline. But by feigning injury all week, they missed out on all the physical and mental preparation of the week. As the season wore on, they could look the part, but their conditioning and physical preparation, or lack thereof, prevented them from actually playing the part meaningfully. Their outside looked prepped. Their insides proved otherwise. As we hone in on a very particular part of the text today, we're attending to our insides a little bit. 1st Samuel 16, verse 7 says this. For the Lord sees not as man sees. Man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart. The Lord isn't concerned about us just wearing the jersey. He's concerned with the heart under the jersey.
4 · Establishes the sermon's thesis, offers an opening prayer, and provides the structural roadmap for the sermon: three movements tracing the heart from misdirection to redirection to redemption
Throughout Scripture, the Lord deals with our hearts. He deals with our personal holiness, understanding that what happens externally is an overflow of our hearts. And today's text is a part of that consistent message throughout Scripture. So our big idea today is church. Attend to your heart and trust the plan of God. Let's pray, Lord, as we dive into your text today to your words. Lord, my words are not the effective ones. Your word is. So make your word effective in our hearts, in our minds, in our hands, and on our lips. In Jesus name, Amen. Because today's text deals with David's anointing as the future king of Israel. And because I got sick a couple weeks ago when we were supposed to talk about Saul's anointing as the king of Israel, we're going. About to talk. Go backwards a little bit. Look at Saul's anointing And juxtapose that with David's anointing as king of Israel. We'll look at this in three parts, all having to do with our heart. First part is a heart misdirected, then a heart redirected, and then a heart redeemed.
5 · Exposes the historical context for understanding Samuel's grief: Israel's repeated pattern of faithfulness, rebellion, consequence, and restoration
A heart misdirected. 1st Samuel 16 begins with a conversation between the Lord and Samuel. The Lord said to Samuel, if you look at verse one, how long will you grieve over Saul, since I have rejected him from being king over Israel? To see why Samuel is grieving here, we need to look back to chapters seven through nine. The rise and fall of Saul is a really compelling narrative all by itself. But it's helpful to view this in terms of the hearts of God's chosen people. Israel is God's chosen people. And we know that throughout their history, beginning with Abraham and continuing, God showed his faithfulness. And then Israel would rebel, and then Israel would face the consequences for their sin against God. And then God would restore his people. This is a pretty common pattern. In this particular period, Israel has been brought back to faithfulness. 1st Samuel Seven Philistines have been defeated. They're living in a time of relative peace. Things are going well until Samuel's sons are appointed and proved to be untrustworthy and dishonest.
Recent preaching context
The three sermons immediately preceding this one in the preaching schedule.
Discuss · apply · pray
Attending to the Heart Together
- What part of the sermon most convicted you about the condition of your own heart—where are you trusting outward appearance or worldly wisdom instead of God's plan?
- As a couple, where might we be more concerned with how we appear to others than how we stand before God, and how can we help each other attend to our hearts together?
- What is one specific area of your spiritual life where you need Christ's healing right now, and how can I pray for you this week as you trust Him as your physician?
5-day reading plan
This week we trace the arc of God's heart-seeing sovereignty: from His rejection of outward appearance, through His sovereign provision of the true king, to our need for Christ the physician, and finally to the hope of transformation under His care.
Saul's external credentials—tall, handsome, from a prominent family—made him the obvious choice by worldly standards. Yet 1 Samuel 9:1-2 shows us the very qualifications that made him appear kingly became the foundation of his spiritual failure, for he never learned to look inward at his own heart before God. We must ask ourselves whether we are building our lives on the same hollow scaffolding of appearance and status that collapsed under Saul.
Saul's rebellion against God's explicit command reveals that outward obedience divorced from a transformed heart is worthless—"rebellion is like the sin of divination, and arrogance like the evil of idolatry." His refusal to fully destroy the Amalekites exposed his love of glory and approval over submission to God's plan. In this we see that no external achievement or appearance can compensate for a heart that refuses to bow before the Lord.
Where Saul failed through misdirected ambition, Isaiah prophesies of a king from Jesse's line whose heart would be fixed entirely on God's pleasure: "The Spirit of the Lord will rest on him." David's anointing and Isaiah's promise both reveal God as the one who sees what we cannot—who discerns the hidden character and shapes history according to His purposes, not ours. We rest in the assurance that our sovereign God sees and provides exactly what His people need.
Just as David was overlooked by his own father and chosen by God despite his humble appearance, Jesus came without form or comeliness that we should desire Him—yet He is the true and better David, the King whom all the world rejected but God exalted. His despised appearance masks the infinite worth of the God-man who came to see and heal our broken hearts. In Him we see that God's choice of leaders and saviors operates by an entirely different logic than the world's.
Our task this week is not merely to confess our misdirected hearts—it is to confess them to the God who is faithful and just to forgive us and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness through Christ. We examine our hearts not to drive us to despair but to drive us to the Savior, who sees all our failure and yet chose to die for us anyway. This is the hope that transforms our hearts: the knowledge that the all-glorious King has already purchased our healing and now reshapes us into His image.
A Prayer for Examined Hearts
Father, we stand before You in awe of Your piercing sight—You alone see not as man sees, looking at outward appearance, but You examine the heart (1 Samuel 16:7). We confess that we, too, are prone to the very misdirection that plagued Israel: we trust in worldly wisdom and external affirmation rather than in Your sovereign plan. We construct carefully curated appearances while neglecting the spiritual condition beneath. We grieve, as Samuel grieved, over the ways we—and those we love—have chosen the world's measure of success over obedience to You.
Yet the gospel invites us to feel our malady so that we might rightly prize our Healer (1 John 1:9). In Jesus, the true and better David, You have given us a King who saw through all pretense and came anyway—who lived perfectly in our place and died as our substitute, covering our sin and reshaping us into His image. By His Spirit, conviction of sin becomes not despair but a grace that drives us nearer to His cross.
We ask, therefore, for courage to examine our own hearts this week. Show us where we are more concerned with how we appear to the world than how we stand before You. Grant us the humility to recognize our ongoing need for the Physician who alone can heal. Free us from both the legalism of external righteousness and the deceit of under-spiritualizing our circumstances. As we encounter the biblical narratives, help us diagnose misdirection in our own hearts, see Your sovereign redirecting work, and rest in Christ's redemption.
May the awareness of our depravity, paired with unwavering confidence in Christ's infallibility, lead us not to despair but to joy. We commit ourselves to press on toward holiness under the care of our all-sufficient Savior, together trusting His plan rather than our own. To Him be glory forever.
What Does God See in You?
This prompt invites your family to reflect on the gap between how they appear on the outside and what's really going on in their hearts. Listen for honesty and help them see that God cares far more about the condition of their hearts than their outward performance—and that Jesus is the one who can change what's inside.
In the sermon, we heard that God doesn't just look at what we do or how we appear—He looks at our hearts. If God looked at your heart today, what would He see? What's something inside you that maybe nobody else knows about?
6 questions for your group this week
-
In 1 Samuel 16:7, God tells Samuel that He looks at the heart, not at outward appearance. What does the sermon identify as the danger of prioritizing how we appear to others or to the world over the condition of our hearts before God?1 Samuel 16:7→ Where in your own life are you most tempted to manage your external image rather than attend to what's actually happening in your heart?
-
The sermon contrasts Saul, who was chosen for his worldly qualifications (1 Samuel 9:1-2), with David, an overlooked shepherd boy. What does this contrast reveal about the difference between how God evaluates a leader and how people typically do?1 Samuel 9:1-2
-
Samuel grieves over Saul's rejection, and the sermon says this grief reveals misdirected hearts in both Samuel and Israel. What were they trusting in instead of God's plan, and why is that same temptation still present for us today?→ Can you think of a time when you've been tempted to trust worldly wisdom or human reasoning over obedience to God's word?
-
The sermon emphasizes that conviction of sin is an ongoing grace that drives us to Christ, our all-sufficient physician. How does the idea that we must 'feel our malady to rightly prize our healer' challenge the way we typically think about examining our hearts?1 John 1:9
-
David's anointing as king was God's sovereign provision—He saw the true king He desired and provided him as a gift to His people despite their failures. How does understanding God's sovereignty over our circumstances and His ongoing faithfulness change the way you approach situations where you're tempted to take control or doubt His plan?→ What does it look like practically this week to rest in Christ's redemption rather than attempt to engineer your own solutions?
-
The sermon culminates in Jesus as the true and better David—the King who chose to come despite seeing our outward failures, who died as a substitute to cover our sin, and who actively reshapes us into His image. Given that Christ sees your heart completely and has already paid the price for it, how should that reshape your motivation for pursuing holiness and attending to your heart's condition?Isaiah 53
1 Samuel 16:7
But the Lord said to Samuel, 'Do not look on his appearance or on the height of his stature, because I have rejected him. For the Lord sees not as man sees: man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart.'
Why this verse: This verse is the theological hinge of the entire sermon—it establishes the central claim that God judges by the heart rather than outward appearance, a truth that reframes how Christians must examine themselves and understand God's character. Committing this verse to memory anchors the congregation in the conviction that their standing before God depends not on worldly qualifications or external performance, but on the condition of their hearts before Him.
About the church
Crawler & AI-search policy · view robots.txt and llms.txt
This sermon page is intentionally optimized for search engines and AI assistants. We've opted into being crawled by both. The crawler-config files at the domain root:
/robots.txt
User-agent: * Allow: / User-agent: GPTBot Allow: / User-agent: ClaudeBot Allow: / User-agent: Google-Extended Allow: / User-agent: PerplexityBot Allow: / Sitemap: https://sermonsteward.com/sitemap.xml
/llms.txt
# Cross of Grace Church A church preaching expository sermons through the books of the Bible. ## Sermons - [A Song for the Betrayed (Psalm 3, 2025-05-25)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/05/a-song-for-the-betrayed) - [Carry The Fire - Week 2 (Ezekiel 37, 2025-06-18)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/06/carry-the-fire-week-2) - [Beware the Lie of the Lizard (Romans 8:1-2, 2025-08-10)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/08/beware-the-lie-of-the-lizard) - [Have You Looked at Your Heart? (1 Samuel 16, 2025-11-09)](/CoGElPaso/sermons/2025/11/have-you-looked-at-your-heart) ## About - [About the church](/about) - [Plan a visit](/visit)
The page itself ships with Schema.org Article + Church markup, Open Graph + Twitter cards for share previews, and a canonical URL. Transcripts are server-rendered HTML — no JS dependency for the readable body.